As of October 2026 · 144 listings tracked across Amazon, Walmart & eBay
Right now the best value is 4.7¢ per oz — Great Value Creamy Peanut Butter, Spread, 64 oz - Free Shipping (64 oz, $3.03) on eBay. See it on eBay →
Prices change fast and stock disappears faster — YMMV.
The pack-size trapThe biggest pack we tracked (239.7 oz) looks like the bulk play, but it runs 13¢ per oz — the 64 oz pick wins at 4.7¢ per oz. Bigger isn't automatically cheaper.
Median across all 144 tracked listings: 16¢ per oz. The worst deal we saw ran $1.01 per oz — same product category, 21.3× the price per unit.
The 12-month picture
Jul 2026low 4.7¢ per oz · high 9.9¢ per ozOct 2026
Best-value price is down 47.4% since last month — a good month to stock up.
Lowest we've ever tracked: 4.7¢ per oz (October 2026).
How we figure this out
Once a month we pull live Peanut Butter listings from Amazon, Walmart and eBay, read the honest quantity out of each one (ozs, in this case — the unit that actually matters), and divide the real price by it. Coupons that change what you'd pay today are applied; "subscribe & save" teasers are not. Then everything gets ranked by cost per oz, because a big box with a small number inside is still a small number.
Our Amazon links are plain links — no affiliate tag, no commission.
Amazon doesn't allow affiliate sites to run price alerts, so we chose the alerts. If eBay or Walmart links ever earn us a commission, they'll be labeled (paid link) — and it never changes the price you pay.
Prices checked October 1, 2026. Prices change fast — treat this page as a map, not gospel, and YMMV. For today's numbers, run a live search.